Thursday, June 22, 2017

Comparison of The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication and Berlo's SMCR Model of Communication

Comparison of The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication and Berlo's SMCR Model of Communication

Communication theory is the branch of knowledge dealing with the principles and methods by which information is conveyed. The communication model is similarly a symbolic representation of the communication process.  It does not show the details of a message rather it presents only those elements which are related to the object of sending a message. It is important to have comparative analysis of communication models because the comparative analysis is especially useful as each example served as a great guide or template for understanding the other. The side by side examination of two or more alternatives, processes, products, qualifications, sets of data, systems, etc., to determine if they have enough common-ground, equivalence, or similarities to permit a meaningful comparative analysis.

Background:

The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication is developed by Dr. Nirmala Mani Adhikary in 2013 through the theory of his doctoral dissertation of “The Bhatta-Mimamsa Philosophical Study of Communication”. This model represents the communication process which shows the interrelation of each elements in interactive manner to show a successful communication process. Each elements plays their role which shows the importance of eastern system of communication process which has the ultimate goal of Arthi Bhavana (feeling to take action).

David K. Berlo, a communication theorist and consultant developed a model named S-M-C-R model of communication in 1960 in his book “The process of communication”. This model of communication is postulated from Shannon Weaver's Model of Communication (1949). He described factors affecting the individual components in the communication making the communication more efficient. Berlo pointed out the importance of the psychological view in his communication model.
The comparative analysis of the eastern communication model Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication and the western Berlo’s S-M-C-R Model of Communication shows the comparison of the features of different communication models and their similarities as well.

Comparative Analysis

Differences
·       The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication contains 11 elements of communication-- 1. Bhavakas (Preshaka, i.e., sender, and Prapaka, i.e., receiver) 2. Bhavana (emotions, moods), 3.  Abhidhan (encoding), 4. Prama (Message), 5. Karan (channel or media), 6. Bodha (decoding), 7. Dosha (Noise), 8. Prakarana (context), 9. Jijnasa (Feedback), 10. Arthi Bhavana (feeling to take an action). These elements are classified under four key themes—Karta , Sadhan , Itikartavyata, and Sadhya)
·       Berlo’s SMCR Model of Communication contains 4 major elements—Source, Message, Channel and Receiver. Under these elements, this model contains the following factors—Source (Communication Skills, Attitudes, Knowledge, Social System, Culture), Message (Content, Elements, Treatment, Structure, Code), Channel (Hearing, Seeing, Touching, Smelling, Tasting), Receiver (Communication Skills, Attitudes, Knowledge, Social System, Culture).

Ø The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication is non-linear i.e. interactive model of communication.
Ø Berlo’s SMCR Model of communication is a linear model of communication.

v The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of communication focuses on encoding and decoding with participatory approach where the Bhavakas (Preshaka, i.e., sender, and Prapaka, i.e., receiver) where the Prama (Message) goes to Abhidhan (encoding) through Karan (channel or media) and comes to Bodha (decoding). The Prama consists of Bhavana (emotions, moods) which also meets with certain Dosha (Noise) in the communication process. According to Prakarana (context) of the Prama, Jijnasa (Feedback) is obtained. The process results to Arthi Bhavana which leads the receiver to take certain action
v Berlo’s SMCR model focuses on encoding and decoding which happens before sender sends the message and before receiver receives the message respectively. The sender sends the message through some channel to the receiver. Since it is a linear model of communication, the sender can become the receiver but with no feedback.

*The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication has the outcome of Arthi Bhavana which means the feeling to take action in the communication process.
*Berlo’s SMCR Model of communication has the outcome of reaching out the message to the receiver where message and medium are aligned with the recipient.

§  The Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication prioritizes the use of sixth sense at the topmost level in terms of communication, since the goal is Arthi Bhavana (the feeling to take action).
§  Berlo’s SMCR model omits the usage of sixth sense as a channel which is actually a gift to the human beings (thinking, understanding, analyzing etc.).

Simiarities

In terms of similarities—both the Bhatta-Mimamsa model of communication and Berlo’s model of communication includes the sender who sends the message through certain channels which gets to the receiver. Both the model contains factors affecting the individual components in the communication making the communication more efficient. Both the Bhatta-Mimamsa Model of Communication and The Berlo’s model of communication takes into account the emotional aspect of the message.

Conclusion

Berlo’s model tries to define all the stages of communication and list all the things that can affect it. But his linear model has become too complex to understand. However, The Bhatta-Mimamsa model expresses the authentic eastern communication process which involves non-linear characteristics and is also not too complex to understand the communication process. The comparative analysis of both the models expresses the process of each communication models with their own peculiar features.








Sunday, April 23, 2017

Jainism

JAINISM

Jain Flag

Jainism is a way of life and one of the oldest religions of the world. It believes in a cyclical nature of universe. It discourages superstition and blind faith and encourages free and rational thinking.
Jainism is an ancient religion from India that teaches that the way to liberation and bliss is to live a life of harmlessness and renunciation.
The aim of Jain life is to achieve liberation of the soul.
Jainism lays heavy emphasis on non-violence (ahimsa) and discipline.
Jains trace their history through a succession of twenty-four teachers and revivers of the Jain path known as Tirthankaras. According to Jain philosophy, all 24 Tirthankaras were born as human beings but they have attained a state of perfection or enlightenment through meditation and self-realization. They are the “Gods” of Jains. Jains have always practiced non-violence, vegetarianism, meditation, yoga, and environmentalism. In the current era, this started with Rishabhdeva and concluded with Mahavira.
Jains believe that Jainism is eternal and while it may be forgotten, it will be revived from time to time.

ORIGIN
              
Jain Om

The word "Jain" derives from the Sanskrit word Jina (conqueror). A human being who has conquered all inner passions like attachment, desire, anger, pride, greed, etc. is called Jina.  Followers of the path practiced and preached by the Jinas are known as Jains.






Parasparopagraho Jivanam ("the function of souls is to help one another") is the motto of Jainism.

FOUNDER

There are three perspectives through which believes in Jainism founders:

1st perspective -Jainism is said to be eternal. From this point of view we cannot name any founder of Jainism in any of the zones. Jainism is believed to be "Anandinidhan", meaning- since time immemorial.

2nd perspective- The first Tirthankara of any half time-cycle can be said to be the founder of Jainism. In this respect Lord Rishabh Dev can be said to be the founder of Jainism for the current half time-cycle. There were similar founders in the other Kshetras. They can be said to be the founders of Jainism for this particular half time-cycle in their respective Kshetras.

3rd perspective- Lord Mahavira the 24th Tirthankara can be said to be the founder of Jainism for the current period. That is why Lord Mahavira is considered to be the most accepted Jainism founder.


Lord Mahavira
Lord Mahavira

Mahavira (Mahāvīra), also known as Vardhamāna, was the twenty-fourth and last Jain Tirthankara (ford maker). In the Jain tradition, it is believed that Mahavira was born into a royal family in what is now Bihar, India, in 599 BC. At the age of 30, he left his home in pursuit of spiritual awakening, and abandoned worldly things, including his clothes, and became a Digambara monk. For the next twelve-and-a-half years, Mahavira practiced intense meditation and severe penance, after which he is believed to have attained Kevala Jnana (omniscience).

After he gained Kevala Jnana, he travelled throughout the Indian subcontinent to teach Jain philosophy. Mahavira taught that the observance of the vows ahimsa (non-violence), satya (truth), asteya (non-stealing), brahmacharya (chastity) and aparigraha (non-attachment) is necessary to spiritual liberation. He gave the principle of Anekantavada (pluralism), Syadvada and Nayavada. The teachings of Mahavira were compiled by Gautama Swami (his chief disciple) and were called Jain Agamas. These texts were transmitted by an oral tradition by Jain monks, but are believed to have been largely lost by about the 1st-century when they were first written down. The surviving versions of the Agamas taught by Mahavira are foundational texts of Jainism. Jains believe Mahavira attained moksha (liberation from the cycle of birth and death) at the age of 72.

FEATURES
Jainism religion has the following basic features:                     
·       Belief on independent existence of soul and matter.
·     Rejection of the idea that a supreme divine creator, owner, preserver or destroyer of the universe exists.
·       Power of karma, eternal universe.
·       Accent on relativity and multiple sides of truth.
·       Morality and ethics based on liberation of soul.


SECTS

Jainism is divided into two major sects

·       Digambara :
The Digambara (meaning sky clad) sect, is the sect of Jainism where monks live completely naked. Digambara monks are not allowed any possessions, not even begging bowls and so can only receive gifts in their cupped hands. Digambara images of tirthankaras have downcast eyes, are plain (and always carved as naked figures).

·       Śvētāmbara:

The Svetambara (meaning white clad) sect, is the sect where monks can have a few possessions such as -- simple white clothing, a begging bowl, a brush to remove insects from their path and books and writing materials. Svetambara images have prominent staring eyes, and are richly decorated.

MAIN PRINCIPLES
Jainism Symbol


The main principles of Jainism are as follows:

·       Ahimsa (non-violence),  
·       Anekantavada (non-absolutism) 
Aparigraha (non-possessiveness)        

MAIN VOWS
There are 5 main vows followed strictly in Jainism:          
·       Ahimsa (non-violence),
·       Satya (not lying),
·       Asteya (not stealing),
·       Brahmacharya (chastity)
·       Aparigraha (non-attachment)

JAIN FESTIVALS

Jainism followers follow different festivals which also include the festivals of Hinduism followers such as Diwali, Navaratri, etc. However the major Jain festivals are as follows:

o  Paryushana or Daslakshana:
Paryushana Parva is one of the most important festival for Jains. Paryusana is formed by two words meaning ‘a year’ and ‘a coming back’. This festival comes in the months of Shravana and Bhadra (August or September). Svetambara Jains celebrate it for eight-days while Digambara Jains celebrate it for ten days. It is also known as Das Lakshana Parva. It is a festival of repentance and forgiveness. Many Jains fast and carry out different religious activities. This festival is believed to remove accumulated karma of the previous year and develop control over new accumulating new karma, by following Jain austerities and other rituals. There are regular rituals at the Jain temples.

o  Mahavir Jayanti:
This festival marks birth of Mahavira. Mahavira Janma Kalyanak (Vardhamana) was born on the thirteenth day of the bright half of the Jain calendar month of Chaitra, probably 599 BCE. It falls in March or April. Procession is carried out and lectures on message of Mahavira is presented. The idols of Mahavira is ceremonially bathed and rocked in a cradle. Events related to birth are also recited from sacred texts by monks.



PRACTICES

Jainism followers follow the practices mentioned as follows:

Ø Vegetarianism: Vegetarianism is a hallmark of Jainism, in accordance with the principle of non-violence towards all beings. Strict followers will also limit dairy products, avoid root vegetables, and avoid eating after sunset.

Ø Fasting: Jains fast throughout the year, particularly during festivals. This takes on various forms and may be practiced based on one's ability. Some examples are: eating only one or two meals per day, drinking only water all day, not eating after sunset, not eating processed foods, and eating food without sugar, oil, or salt.


Ø Prayers: In Jainism, the purpose of prayer is to break the barriers of worldly attachments and desires and to assist in the liberation of the soul. Jains do not pray for any favors, material goods, or rewards.

Ø Meditation: Jains have developed a type of meditation called Sāmāyika, a term derived from the word Samaya. The goal of Sāmāyika is to achieve a feeling of perfect calmness and to understand the unchanging truth of the self.

Ø Festivals: Paryushana or Daslakshana is the most important annual event for Jains, and is usually celebrated in August or September. It lasts eight to ten days and is a time when lay people increase their level of spiritual intensity often using fasting and prayer/meditation to help. The five main vows are emphasized during this time. Mahavir Jayanti, the birth of Mahāvīra, the last tirthankara of this era, is usually celebrated in late March or early April based on the lunar calendar. Some other festivals celebrated by Jains are Diwali, Akshaya Tritiya and Raksha Bandhan.


Ø Rituals: There are many rituals in Jainism's various sects. The basic worship ritual practised by Jains is darsana ("seeing") of pure self in Jina idols.

Ø Pilgrimages: Jain Tirtha ("pilgrim") sites are divided into the following categories:
o  Siddhakshetra – Site of the moksha of an arihant (kevalin) or Tirthankara, such as: Ashtapada, Shikharji, Girnar, Pawapuri, Palitana, Mangi-Tungi, and Champapuri (capital of Anga).
o  Atishayakshetra – Locations where divine events have occurred, such as: Mahavirji, Rishabhdeo, Kundalpur, Tijara, and Aharji.
o  Puranakshetra – Places associated with lives of great men, such as: Ayodhya, Vidisha, Hastinapur, and Rajgir.
o  Gyanakshetra – Places associated with famous acharyas, or centers of learning, such as Shravanabelagola.

Ø Monasticism: In Jainism, monasticism is encouraged and respected. Monks and nuns live extremely serious and ascetic lifestyles. They follow the five main vows strictly, and observe complete self-discipline. Jain monks, whose presence is not needed for most Jain rituals, should not be confused with priests. Some Jain sects often employ a pujari, who need not be a Jain, to perform special daily rituals and other priestly duties at the temple.

PHILOSOPHY

According to the Jain Philosophy, there are seven fundamentals (the seven Tattvas or realities in Jainism) through which the living cycle in the world is continued. They are as follows:

v Jiva (i. e. living substance)
v Ajiva (i. e. matter or non-living substance)
v Asrava (i. e., the influx of Karmic matter in the soul)
v Bandha (i. e., bondage of soul by Karmic matter)
v Samvara (i. e., the stopping of Asrava)
v Nirjara (i. e., the gradual removal of Karmic matter)
v Moksha (i. e., the attainment of perfect freedom or salvation)

EPISTEMOLOGY

Jains maintain that knowledge is the nature of the soul. In Jainism, jnāna (knowledge) is said to be of five kinds—
v Kevala Jnana (Omniscience)
v Śrutu Jñāna (Scriptural Knowledge)
v Mati Jñāna (Sensory Knowledge)
v Avadhi Jñāna (Clairvoyance)
v Manah prayāya Jñāna (Telepathy)
According to Jain text Tattvartha sutra, the first two are indirect knowledge and the remaining three are direct knowledge.

ONTOLOGY

Harry Oldmeadow notes that Jain ontology is both realist and dualist metaphysics.

It is realist in the sense that knowledge of ultimate reality does not exclude the reality of the existing world; the enlightened worldview includes the knowledge of particulars and the world continues to be real even after the liberation.

It is dualist in the sense that the two prime categories of substance, soul and matter, are mutually exclusive.

LOGIC

v Syād-vāda - Syād-vāda in Jainism believes in the doctrine of qualified assertion. As reality is complex, no single proposition can express the nature of reality fully. It focuses on what is reality. The belief that truth itself is multiple is followed according to this logic.

v Anekānta-vāda - Anekānta-vāda views truth from many viewpoints. It focuses on how to attain knowledge. The belief that there are multiple ways to attain the truth is followed according to this logic. It refers to the principles of pluralism and multiplicity of viewpoints, the notion that truth and reality are perceived differently from diverse points of view and that no single point of view is the complete truth.

METAPHYSICS

According to Jain thought, the basic constituents of reality are:

v Jiva (Souls),
v Pudgala (matter)
v Dharma (motion)
v Adharma (rest)
v Akasa (space)
v Kala (time)

ETHICS

The Maha Vratas (major vows) of Jainism observed by the Jain ascetics are as follows:

v Ahiṃsā (Non-violence)
v Satya (Truth)
v Asteya (Non-stealing)
v Brahmacharya (Chastity)
v Aparigraha (Non-possession)

JAIN LITERATURE

Basically, the Jain Literature is divided into following two types:

§  Agam or Canonical Literature (Agam Sutras): They are the sacred books of the Jain religion. They are written in the Ardha-magadhi Prakrit language compiled by Ganadharas and Srut-kevlis.

§  Non-Agam Literature: they are the commentary and explanation of Agam literature, and independent works, compiled by ascetics and scholars. They are written in many languages such as Prakrit, Sanskrit, Apabhramsa, Old Marathi, Rajasthani, Gujarati, Hindi, Kannad, Tamil, German, and English.

FOUR ANUYOGAS IN JAIN LITERATURE

§  Pratham anuyoga (Dharma kath anuyoga) - Religious Stories
·       Padma puran- Ravisen (650 AD)
·       Harivamsa puran- Jinsen II (783 AD)
·       Adi puran- Jinsen II (783 AD)
·       Uttar puran- Gunabhadra (879 AD)

§  Charn anuyoga – Conduct
·       Mulachar- Vattaura (600 AD)
·       Trivarnachar – Vattaura (600 AD)
·       Ratna karanda shravak achar- Samantabhadra (600 AD)

§  Karan anuyoga (Ganit anuyog) - Mathematics:
·       Surya prajnapti (Unknown)
·       Chandra prajnapti (Unknown)
·       Jaya dhaval tika- Virsen/Jinsen (780 AD)
·       Gommat sar- Nemichandra Siddhant (1000 AD)

§  Dravy anuyog - Philosophy:
·       Niyamasar- Kunda kunda (100 AD)
·       Panchastikaya- Kunda kunda (100 AD)
·       Pravachanasar - Kunda kunda (100 AD)
·       Samaya sara- Kunda kunda (100 AD)
·       Tattvartha sutra- Umaswami (200 AD)
·       Commentary on Tattvartha sutra- Samantabhadra (600 AD)
·       Commentary on Tattvartha sutra- Pujyapad (700 AD)
·       Commentary on Tattvartha sutra- Akalank (750 AD)
·       Commentary on Tattvartha sutra- Vidyanand (800 AD)
·       Aptamimamsa- Samantabhadra (600 AD)
·       Commentary on Aptmimamsa - Akalank (750 AD)
·       Commentary on Aptmimamsa - Vidyanand (800 AD)

JAIN PHILOSOPHERS

The 24 Tirthankaras of each time are considered to be the main philosophers in Jainism. They are mentioned as follows:

1                  Rishabhanatha (Adinatha)
2                  Ajitanatha  
3                  Sambhavanatha
4                  Abhinandananatha
5                  Sumatinatha
6                  Padmaprabha     
7                  Suparshvanatha
8                  Chandraprabha
9                  Pushpadanta
10            Shitalanatha
11            Shreyanasanatha
12            Vasupujya
13            Vimalanatha      
14            Anantanatha
15            Dharmanatha     
16            Shantinatha
17            Kunthunatha
18            Aranatha
19            Munisuvrata
20            Māllīnātha
21            Naminatha
22            Neminatha
23            Parshvanatha      
24            Mahavira

Apart from the 24 Tirthankaras, the followings are also some of the names of the Jain philosophers:

·       Kundakunda (1st—2nd century CE)                                       
·       Samantabhadra (2nd century CE)                 
·       Umāsvāti or Umasvami (2nd century CE)            
·       Siddhasena Divākara (5th century)
·       Akalanka (5th century)                                                  
·       Pujyapada (6th century)                        
·       Manikyanandi (6th century)                  
·       Jinabhadra (6th–7th century)
·       Mallavadin (8th century)       
·       Haribhadra ( 8th century)
·       Prabhacandra(8th-9th century)
·       Abhayadeva (1057-1135)
·       Acharya Hemachandra (1089-1172)
·       Vadideva ( 11th century)
·       Vidyanandi ( 11th century)
·       Yasovijaya (1624-1688)

COMMUNITIES

The majority of Jains reside in India. (6-7 million followers)
Outside of India, some of the largest Jain communities are present in Canada, Europe, Kenya, the UK, Suriname, Fiji, and the United States.

TEMPLES

Jain followers consider some pilgrimage sites as their religious, holy and sacred sites. Some of such temples are mentioned as follows:

·       Lal Mandir.
·       Sonagiri.
·       Khajuraho Jain Temples.
·       Gomateshwara Temple.
·       Dilwara Temples.
·       Palitana.

·     Ranakpur Temple.

Media Coverage of Asia Pacific Conference: A Comparative Study of The Kathmandu Post, The Himalayan Times and My Republica The Asia-Pac...